We all saw the pictures from ACL mudfest: loaders churning through mud, crews rolling turf over a soaked Great Lawn. The festival is gone, but the questions it left behind, and questions about the City's complicity, are not. Free Zilker follows a deep dive with one Austin resident, Diana Prechter, as she tries to uncover city leaders' silence on the matter.

Green Turf covers up the muddy pits made by the estimated 75,000 people during the first weekend of ACL.
Follow the Money
Diana Prechter, an Austin resident and self-described citizen researcher, runs Today in Zilker Park and has spent years pursuing clarity and transparency from the City and Austin Parks and Recreation Department in their management of Zilker Park. Mostly working solo, she is often seen at the Austin Parks Board and City Hall, fighting to keep Zilker Park and Barton Springs ecologically viable, and accessible to the public.
On November 4, Prechter submitted a formal audit request to the Office of the City Auditor for an investigation into the City Manager's oversight and accountability for the management, protection, and financial stewardship of Zilker Park. She cited four specific concerns: park damage, the ACL contract, lack of financial accountability, and the long-term sustainability of City park policies. Her request draws almost entirely on the City's own documents.
Defacing City Property: What the City’s Own Rules Say
PARD's event policy, incorporated into C3's contract, states that receiving one-half inch of rain or less in a single day, or accumulated over several days, "will likely make park grounds unusable for event purposes of any nature." About 1.3 to 1.5 inches fell on October 1, the last load-in day, and another 0.6 inch fell on October 2, the first day of the festival. The October 1 rainfall alone was roughly three times the threshold PARD identifies.
The ACL agreement itself states: "The Organizer agrees that continuing an event during rain without the approval of the City is defacing of City property."
Prechter asked the City for documents, memos, or emails indicating any approval to continue in the rain. The answer, on October 28: ""The City of Austin has no responsive documents to your request." Both departments that manage the ACL agreement confirmed they found no records of approval or records of rain or wet-ground damage. By the contract's own definition, continuing the event during rain without City approval would constitute "defacing" City property. Why wasn't ACL delayed when rainfall exceeded the threshold PARD identifies as likely to make park grounds unusable? What consideration did the City give to the risk of damage to public parkland? Those questions remain unanswered.

Mud, standing water, and damaged turf on Zilker Park's Great Lawn following ACL

Brown, patchy grass and lingering signs of damage across the Great Lawn after the festival

What defacement looked like
Damage to the Butler Landfill Cap

Overhead view of Zilker Park's Great Lawn, with the blue arrow indicating the Butler Landfill area
Few Austinites know that ACL trucks and equipment are staged on top of a closed city landfill. The Butler Landfill, along Stratford Drive, received municipal waste from 1948 to 1967. Its clay cap covers approximately 100,000 cubic yards of buried waste, and the bottom of the waste sits in the water of Lady Bird Lake. A 2019 environmental assessment identified contaminants in groundwater above recommended levels, including arsenic, barium, cadmium, chromium, magnesium, lead, iron, and manganese, and classified the landfill as a recognized environmental condition. Although the assessment found no hazardous materials in water draining from the landfill, the potential environmental concerns warrant continued attention.
Could landfill-related contaminants pose risks to wildlife, people, or dogs who use the park? Could runoff carry contaminants into Lady Bird Lake? These are questions that warrant further investigation by the City, the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality (TCEQ), and, if necessary, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA).
- The engineer who designed the 2022 paver grid for the staging area wrote that the grass and soil over the cap "will reduce their strength when wet."
- City staff told the Environmental Commission in 2018 that staging on the cap was "an interim and short-term solution" and that "use when wet causing rutting and depressions is not acceptable."
- On October 31, Prechter found sections of the paver grid dug out of the cap and piled with mulch, fence rails, and lumber. On November 2, the day after she asked Watershed Protection to inspect it, the pile was hauled away.
- Watershed Protection confirmed in writing that the damage "happened during load-in for ACL" and that the Parks Department and C3 "were both aware of it." In response to an earlier public information request, Parks said it had no records of the damage.
- But in a November 6 email, Parks Assistant Director Liana Kallivoka said staff observed the damage at the beginning of ACL load-in, matting was laid over it for the remainder of the event, and C3 had the original contractor repair it. Diana's November 5 photographs show the repair underway. Whether the state environmental agency (TCEQ) was notified remains an open question.
Silence From YOUR Leaders:
A 15-Year Contract Without Consideration for Constituents
The 2025 ACL agreement runs through 2040. Each year’s fees are set in a scope of work that only C3 signs. Compare Austin’s deal with the one C3 signed with Chicago for Lollapalooza in 2022.
| Austin ACL (2025) | Chicago Lollapalooza (2022) | |
| Runs through | 2040 | 2032 |
| Guaranteed payment | None | $2,000,000 a year |
| If no festival is held | Nothing | $750,000 |
| If C3 walks away | 30 days’ notice | $250,000 to $2,000,000 |
| Revenue share and audit rights | $2,500 damage deposit | 5% to 20% of festival revenue; City can audit |
| Park restoration | C3 restores at its own cost; $2,500 refundable deposit; no independent assessment. | Independent before-and-after assessment; C3 pays full cost |
Same company, very different terms.
Where Is the Money?
In August 2025, Council directed the City Manager to create a Parks Enhancement Fund, paid for by the new per-ticket park maintenance fee. City records released under a public information request show that ACL paid $1,449,768 in per-ticket fees for 2025.
The City has not yet shown the public where that money went; Prechter’s request for the records is still pending.
Prechter argues that all ticketed public events, including co-sponsored events, should be required to collect the Tiered Special Event Park Maintenance Fee rather than receive waivers. She considers this a practical way to generate revenue for the Parks Enhancement Fund, with the fee passed along to ticket buyers rather than absorbed by event organizers.
The fund has not yet been included in the City's budget.
The 2025 Scope of Work lists $500 a day for set-up and take-down and $5,000 a day on festival days. It separately lists October 18–31 as “park maintenance week,” with C3 fencing the south edge of the Great Lawn, but shows no fee for those dates. Whether C3 is charged for additional days when park areas remain fenced off is a question the City has yet to answer.
Those rates have not changed since 2010. Why are taxpayers not compensated for the weeks the park is fenced off to the public for ACL and its recovery?
What Prechter Is Asking For
- One-year contracts rather than 15-year agreements, with an independent engineer certifying the landfill cap before and after each event; mandatory cancellation protections similar to those in place for Chicago’s Lollapalooza; and formal, written weather and ground-condition protocols establishing clear standards for postponement or cancellation, with designated City officials required to inspect conditions and authorize an event to proceed when the ground is saturated.
- Fully implement the Parks Enhancement Fund now, deposit the 2025 ACL fee in it, and publicly report the fund’s receipts and expenditures every year.
- Adopt a Zilker Park Impact Fee, paid to the City and scaled to the portion of parkland the festival closes each day. Prechter’s rough estimate of potential annual revenue is $278,000 to $556,000. The money could go to a Zilker Park Environmental Impact Fund for the landfill cap, soil, water quality, and trees, with the public voting on projects through participatory budgeting. The funds would remain with the City rather than going to nonprofit partners.
The City’s own consultants, PFM and the Trust for Public Land, recommended in their 2025 report that Austin “consider a Park Impact Fee” for events like ACL.
Where Free Zilker Stands
Free Zilker maintains that ACL is causing consistent, long-term, and potentially irreparable damage to Zilker Park and should be relocated. The current agreement between the City and C3 allows either party to terminate with 30 days' notice, providing the City an opportunity to reconsider the festival's future in Zilker before the next annual scope of work is signed. Austin need not lose the economic benefits of ACL by moving it. Other venues, including Circuit of the Americas (COTA) and the Travis County Expo Center, could be considered as alternative locations where the festival could continue generating income and economic activity for the region.
Prechter’s request doesn’t change that position; it asks the City to account for what is happening right now, under an agreement either party can terminate with 30 days’ notice, before C3 signs the next annual scope of work.
Audit and Finance Committee: Ask that Prechter’s audit request be taken up before ACL 2027.
-
- City Council (December 2026) or the Climate, Water, Environment and Parks Committee (January 2027, when the City Manager is directed to report on park fees for ticketed events): Speak in support of a Zilker Park Impact Fee.
- Parks and Recreation Board and Environmental Commission: Email or speak to the boards and ask for an agenda item on ACL staging on the landfill cap.
- Email your Council member to express your concerns.But in a November 6 email, Parks Assistant Director Liana Kallivoka said staff observed the damage at the beginning of ACL load-in, matting was laid over it for the remainder of the event, and C3 had the original contractor repair it. Diana's November 5 photographs show the repair underway. Whether the state environmental agency (TCEQ) was notified remains an open question. Silence From YOUR Leaders: A 15-Year Contract Without Consideration for Constituents
What You Can Do
Speak Out!
Any or all of the following are important points to raise with City Council and other City entities.
Prechter calls it a menu: choose the issue that matters most to you and speak up.
SIGN THE MOVE ACL PETITION
